Football can overtake cricket in India in terms of popularity
View – Jonathan Piers
I stepped onto the pitch, the crowd on their feet, chanting my name; being an Indian that day among some of the world’s greatest, to stand out, to perform, filled my heart with pride. I felt I made my nation proud, that I contributed a few drops to the ocean of change flooding over sports lovers in our nation. Football is becoming one of the dominant forces in Indian sport. Our people are coming around to understand the beauty of this universal sport, and are beginning to comprehend and appreciate what this sport has to offer.
The Indian Super League came knocking on Indian doors in 2013. We had the I-league before that which, unfortunately, was not really well covered by the media. Since the ISL entered the picture, the viewership boomed. It became the 4th most watched football league in the world. Renowned cricketers themselves invested in the teams that participated, like Sourav Ganguly and Sachin Tendulkar owned Atlético de Kolkata and Kerala Blasters respectively. Since then, it has just been getting bigger and bigger. With the introduction of Premier Futsal, things got a whole lot better for Indian football. Big names like Paul Scholes, Ronaldhino and Ryan Giggs, along with some of the best futsal players in the world, drew some of the biggest, most crazy crowds to flock the stadiums and watch these legends rub shoulders with their fellow Indians and take the footballing world by storm. Think about it this way – players who have won everything there is to win in the game, are in our backyard. Football fans around the world would kill to watch these men play live again. Let’s not forget the ‘wow’ factor that it had. To call it a spectacle would be a massive understatement. It was an entertainment galore.
This is not to say cricket will ever lose its value. Nor is it to say football will be the new religion in this country anytime soon. But it will be the next big thing in a decade or more. If you told someone in the street, ten years ago that football in India would be where it is today, they would have told you to go fly a kite. But it is here, and it’s here to stay. At this rate every Indian, when born, will have a football at his or her feet and not a cricket bat.
Counter view – Ajay Ramakrishnan
“Sachin! Sachin! Sachin!”- it would be futile to count how many times that chant has lifted the nation, brought light to the darkest corners where hope was all but lost, and united a country that is built on foundations of difference.
Cricket in India is not just a sport, it is an emotion. It has not succeeded on the merit of the game alone, but with the love of the people. It is ingrained in the very fabric of the nation. So much so, that it is hard to imagine a world where one can exist without the other. Where football owes its growth to the rising popularity of foreign leagues like the Spanish La Liga and the English Premier League among the middle and upper classes, cricket has its roots firmly set in the lower classes, and branches out to all levels of society; and it is the lower class, as we know, that is the overwhelming majority of the Indian population.
Now you may say it’s all well and good to look at things from an emotional perspective that isn’t really tangible, but the reality on ground backs these views. Both government as well as private aid and infrastructure is well developed for cricket, while being woefully inadequate for football. To illustrate the extent of the existing difference between the two sports, let us look at their most popular domestic leagues. Though we have had the recent introduction of the Indian Super League, marketed as the premier destination for quality and talent to promote and popularize football, few know that this league is not even recognized by FIFA or the Asian Football Confederation. It’s attendance and viewership pale in comparison to cricket’s Indian Premier League, with the IPL reaching a total viewership of 568 million in its 2017 edition, while the ISL had less than half that number at 216 million. And when you take into account the fact that the IPL broadcasts for a month and a half as opposed to the ISL’s three months, the extent of the chasm between them truly comes into clearer perspective.
You may also argue that football has come a long way, and that the present situation shows grounds for enough growth to overtake cricket. But if a sport has to grow to be the biggest among its peers on the national level, it can only do so with the support of the people of the nation. And therein lies football’s biggest hurdle, one that I daresay is insurmountable considering the foundation of cricket popularity lying with the majority lower class of the population. We all love an underdog story, but when the love and support for the underdog is with the minority, it’s chances are slim to none at best.